Liftsmith

Barbell row vs one-arm dumbbell row

Both work the upper back and lats as main movers.

The Barbell row, with the muscles it works lit up
Barbell row
The One-arm dumbbell row, with the muscles it works lit up
One-arm dumbbell row

Side by side

Barbell rowOne-arm dumbbell row
Main musclesUpper back, LatsLats, Upper back
Also worksRear delts, Biceps, Lower backRear delts, Biceps
EquipmentBarbellDumbbells, Flat bench
MovementHorizontal pullHorizontal pull
TypeCompound (several joints)Compound (several joints)
Start for 10 reps, 80 kg man37.5 kg (85 lb)20 kg (40 lb) per dumbbell
Start for 10 reps, 65 kg womanThe empty bar9 kg (21 lb) per dumbbell

Starting weights are for someone with some experience, rounded to plates and dumbbells a gym has. New lifters start lighter.

When to pick each

Barbell row
A good pick when this is your kit: barbell.
One-arm dumbbell row
One arm at a time with support.

As a swap for each other

Among the swaps Liftsmith offers for the barbell row, the one-arm dumbbell row ranks 18 of 113.

Among the swaps Liftsmith offers for the one-arm dumbbell row, the barbell row ranks 2 of 113.

Questions

Is the barbell row or the one-arm dumbbell row better?
Neither is better for everyone; it depends on what you want from the lift. Barbell row: A good pick when this is your kit: barbell. One-arm dumbbell row: One arm at a time with support.
Do the barbell row and the one-arm dumbbell row work the same muscles?
Both work the upper back and lats as main movers.
Which needs less equipment, the barbell row or the one-arm dumbbell row?
For the barbell row: barbell. For the one-arm dumbbell row: dumbbells and flat bench.

More comparisons

The right lift for the gym you're in

Tell Liftsmith your equipment once. Every workout uses lifts you can do there, with the weight and reps worked out for you.

Start free in your browser

Swap exercises in one tap

Start free